Kyle directed me to
this rant which so completely captured the zeitgeist of this musical age that I had to link it. I really hope that it gets a lot of eyeballs, because it really crystallized for me a lot of things I had been feeling since Oink went down recently.
There have been only 2 online services I have ever seen that acheived a library complete enough to offer a large
Stockhausen discography: Napster, very shortly before it was closed down, and Oink, for over six months. I choose stockhausen because he is a relatively big fish in the relatively small pond of 20th-century electronic composition. It's not just that I like that style of music, it's that, to me, that is the real promise of the intersection of the internet and music. I would really love to see a stable, reliable, source for ALL music, no matter how obscure. Actually, the more obscure the better. Nobody has trouble getting the latest britney spears record, but the 40 or so people that really want to hear the
1933 recording of Ionization are going to have a hard time through traditional channels.
Music appreciation has changed so much from when I was a teenager. I used to spend a LOT of time going to various record stores, and talking to strangers about my favorite bands. I had no official discography source- periodically, I'd just manage to find a previously unknown album recorded by one of my favorite bands, and it was as if some god was rewarding my peculiar sense of devotion. It would immediately be copied to many many tapes and distributed to the 16 or so other people I knew that would desperately want their own copy. That's just the way it worked. The record companies weren't aware that they were losing money, because it would cost them more money to stock
Brown Reason to Live in San Diego than they would make through sales of the few people who would want it.
Now that kids have amazon, band fansites, and generally access to a few orders of magnitude more information than I did, the form their mania takes will certainly be very different than it was for my generation. But I still think that sharing will be a huge part of it, and that they will love the bands that they find. Love them. Want the best for them. Support them. I really believe that no matter what distribution model is finally selected, bands that really reach their listeners will find that their listeners want to take care of them. What nobody really is that interested in supporting is the sybaritic, outmoded, parasite that RIAA labels have become.